Legacy Traps

Here's an interesting dialogue from #perl6 yesterday:
TimToady  but the fact is, Perl 5 is basically in a no-win
          situation long term, which we first recognized in
          2000
PerlJam   TimToady: now you're alienating all the staunch perl
          5 supporters  :)
TimToady  I'm only alienating them "long term"
KyleHa    If loving Perl 5 is wrong, I don't want to be right.
          8-)
PerlJam   Someone mentioned (probably on use.perl somewhere)
          that Nicholas tried regular release cycles a while
          back.  I'd like to know if that's true and if so,
          what became of it.
ruoso     I don't really think the regular releases is the
          issue...
TimToady  I love Perl 5 too, but it's stuck (culturally, and
          maybe technically) in a legacy trap, and the Perl 6
          approach is the only long-term way out of that.
moritz_   ruoso: it's not about *regular*, but about being
          able to release when there's something to fix
TimToady  Perl 5 is a velociraptor, but we need an
          acceloraptor now.

There ought to be a corollary to that saying about "Fast, Good and Cheap. -Pick any two". -Something to deal with legacy vs. innovation and revolution vs. evolution. But I suppose the latter is fundamentally a balance between looking backward while moving forward, the threshold of pain you're willing to undergo, and how you attempt to minimize it.

I wouldn't pretend to have the experience or wisdom to find the right balance. However, it doesn't appear to be a new problem.

C++ went through a period of upheaval not too long ago. There was a nice Dr. Dobb's article on it back in 1997. Well worth reading.

Here's a Linux kernel developers thread on the same topic of evolution and change. -A nugget from Theodore Tso:
"Clearly, we are right to mock Solaris for making claims that
they will never, ever, *ever* change an interface, not even
one that goes back sixteen years to Solaris 2.3.  But it
doesn't follow the opposite point of view, that constant
mutability of kernel interfaces to make sure that things are
always perfect and pure and clean is the right one either."

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Raku: Advent of Code 2020 - Day Twelve

Below are my Raku solutions to Day Twelve puzzles for the 2020 Advent of Code. No effort was put into making things cleverly concise.  #!/usr/bin/env raku use v6.d ; my $face = 'E' ; my $c = <E S W N> ; # compass my %c = ( E => 0 , S => 1 , W => 2 , N => 3 ); # reverse lookup my ( $x , $y ) = ( 0 , 0 ); # ship location 'input' . IO . lines . map ({ my ( $direction , $qty ) = ( ~. substr ( 0 , 1 ) , +. substr ( 1 )); $direction = $face if $direction eq 'F' ; given $direction { when 'N' { $y += $qty } when 'S' { $y -= $qty } when 'E' { $x += $qty } when 'W' { $x -= $qty } when 'L' { my $i = %c { $face }; $i -= $qty div 90 ; $i = $i mod 4 ; $face = $c [ $i ]; } when 'R' { my $i = %c { $face }; $i += $qty div 90 ; $i = $i mod 4 ; $face = $c [ $i ]; } } }); say "Part One: { abs ( $x ) + abs ( $y )} "
Read more

Raku: Setting up Raku (for Contributors)

[last revised/updated 2020_10_03] Foreword This series of posts on Raku programming attempts to be succinct and useful for folks interested in contributing to Raku. If you find it useful, drop me a note in the comments. -Ofun Posts in the Series Try Raku! (work in progress) Setting up Raku (for Contributors) [this post] Wading into the Raku community (planned) Setting up Raku (for Contributors) When you use Raku and interact with others, your interactions affect the community. Raku is a welcoming community. You are welcome. Pull up a chair and get comfy. These instructions will help you get up and running Raku in a configuration that enables you to contribute back when you are ready. To enable contributing, we will setup hosted copies ('forks') of the Rakudo, NQP, and MoarVM git repositories on Github. Your changes (when you are ready to make them) will go into your repositories. You will submit requests which allow others to pull your changes upstream i
Read more

Raku: Advent of Code 2020 - Day Thirteen

Raku solutions to Day Thirteen of the 2020 Advent of Code. Today's puzzle involved bus routes. Part One requires you to figure out which route id will arrive closest to a timestamp. The answer to Part Two involves identifying when an alignment of departure times across route ids will occur. #!/usr/bin/env raku use v6.d ; my ( $depart , $line ) = 'input' . IO . slurp . split ( " \n " ); $depart .= Int ; say "Part One: " ~ [*] $line . split ( ',' ) . grep ( none 'x' ) ». Int . map ({ $_ , $_ - ( $depart ) mod $_ }) . min ({ . [ 1 ] }) . flat ; # index of @l is the offset from factor my @l = $line . split ( ',' ); my ( $r , $factor ) = ( 0 , @l [ 0 ] . Int ); for 1 ..^ @l -> $i { next if @l [ $i ] eq 'x' ; $r = ( $r , { $_ + $factor } ... -> $a { ( $a + $i ) mod @l [ $i ] . Int == 0 }) . tail ; $factor *= @l [ $i ]; } say "Part Two: $r " ; Part One Given the sample inpu
Read more